Spain’s Central Economic-Administrative Court (TEAC) has set out its position on reimbursing the cost of guarantees provided to suspend a tax debt. Only the taxpayer is entitled to reimbursement, even if a third party paid the bank guarantee fees.
What is this right?
When taxpayers appeal a tax assessment or penalty, they can suspend collection by providing a guarantee, usually a bank guarantee. If the debt is later found to be wholly or partly unfounded, by an administrative decision or a final court ruling, the tax authorities must reimburse the cost of that guarantee, plus statutory interest (Article 33 of the General Taxation Law and its implementing regulations).
In practice, the guarantee is often paid for by someone else, such as the group’s parent company, a shareholder or a family member. The question was who is entitled to claim the reimbursement in that case.
What does the TEAC say?
- Only the taxpayer whose debt was secured is entitled to reimbursement.
- It makes no difference that a third party paid the guaranteed fees.
- The taxpayer does not have to prove they have repaid the third party.
- Private agreements between the parties do not change who holds this right before the tax authorities.
What does this mean in practice?
The third party who paid for the guarantee cannot claim reimbursement directly from the Spanish Tax Agency. The claim must come from the taxpayer. How the third party is compensated falls outside the relationship with the tax authorities and must be settled privately, as agreed between the parties.
We therefore recommend:
- Documenting from the outset who bears the cost of the guarantee and how they will be compensated if it is reimbursed.
- Reviewing proceedings involving cancelled debts where another entity paid for the guarantee, so the taxpayer can claim reimbursement within the deadline.
- In corporate groups, planning the accounting and tax treatment of the reimbursement and of passing it on to the entity that paid.
The addwill Tax Department will keep a close eye on how this position develops. Please don’t hesitate to get in touch if you have any questions.
Author:
Mireia Zapata
Manager, Tax Department, addwill